Minutes London 2008 - Revision history

Piotr Banski: + category

2009-01-29T11:26:00Z

+ category

Hildeboe: /* I textual alteration */

2008-11-26T14:50:53Z

‎I textual alteration

Hildeboe at 14:50, 26 November 2008

2008-11-26T14:50:15Z

Fotis Jannidis: /* Agenda */

2008-11-14T18:32:31Z

‎Agenda

Fotis Jannidis at 18:30, 14 November 2008

2008-11-14T18:30:46Z

Fotis Jannidis: New page: present: Hilde Boe, Fotis Jannidis, Federico Meschini, Malte Rehbein, Elena Pierazzo, Justin Tonra discussion led by Elena, minutes by Fotis [I forgot to take down the names of all present...

2008-11-14T18:29:52Z

New page: present: Hilde Boe, Fotis Jannidis, Federico Meschini, Malte Rehbein, Elena Pierazzo, Justin Tonra discussion led by Elena, minutes by Fotis [I forgot to take down the names of all present...

New page

present: Hilde Boe, Fotis Jannidis, Federico Meschini, Malte Rehbein, Elena Pierazzo, Justin Tonra
discussion led by Elena, minutes by Fotis
[I forgot to take down the names of all present, so please add yours in case I missed it.]

4 groups of problems:

<ol start="I">
<li>textual alterations etc. </li>
<li>time</li>
<li>grouping changes</li>
<li>a coordinate system for relation of different witnesses</li>
<li>expressing of the interpretation of sequences</li>
<li>Uncertainty</li>
</ol>

===I textual alteration===
Addition, deletion, transposition, clarification, substition (should allow for cases like stylisitic rewriting and total rewriting, looser way), restoration, overwriting, immediate/instant correction, functional mark (marked as used, printer marks, later scribe marks), gap for a planned insertion (which has been filled or not)

===II. Time===
Should note: Sequence and Timeline (calender)
Not all elements of the text can be attributed exactly to one sequence or nt at all
Only some some elements can be dated exactly
Sequences are not monolinear, but can branch etc.
It should be possible to make implicit sequences explicit

Sentences become agramatical by corrections; marking the level of correction where this becomes necessary

We have to allow editors to choose what elements they want to choose

Sequence / time information should be kept on an own level as standoff markup

===III. grouping changes on a page===
On a document
revision
text stage -

on a macro level
grouping textblocks

===IV. a coordinate system for relation of different witnesses===
There is the need to choose an coordinate reference, ether by using the last version or another text or an abstract model of the text. The model should make it possible to reference all text elements (verses, lines, sentences…)

===V. expressing of the interpretation of sequences ===
Free text, typified arguments should also be possible

===VI. Uncertainty===
Adding to the exisitng TEI-schema
Add rankings: this is the most probable way (or more probable than 2 or 3 etc)
Add relations: this constellation is more probably than that constellation.

===Agenda===
1) Proposal for money for the workshop
2) Meeting in Oxford with James / or Sebastian in Oxford (January would be possible)
3) Fotis puts minutes on the wiki, link to a google doc
4) Malte organizes dates for skype conferences

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:26, 29 January 2009
Line 1:		Line 1:
		+	[[Category:London 2008]]
	present: Hilde Bøe, Fotis Jannidis, Federico Meschini, Malte Rehbein, Elena Pierazzo, Justin Tonra, Ellen Nessheim Wiger.		present: Hilde Bøe, Fotis Jannidis, Federico Meschini, Malte Rehbein, Elena Pierazzo, Justin Tonra, Ellen Nessheim Wiger.
	Discussion led by Elena, minutes by Fotis		Discussion led by Elena, minutes by Fotis

@@ Line 17: / Line 17: @@
 Addition, deletion, transposition, clarification, substition (should allow for cases like stylisitic rewriting and total rewriting, looser way), restoration, overwriting, immediate/instant correction, functional mark (marked as used, printer marks, later scribe marks), gap for a planned insertion (which has been filled or not)
-Here are Hilde Bøe's slides with examples from Henrik Ibsen's manuscripts: <a href="http://www.emunch.no/tei-mm-2008/index_ms.html">http://www.emunch.no/tei-mm-2008/index_ms.html</a>
+Here are Hilde Bøe's slides with examples from Henrik Ibsen's manuscripts: http://www.emunch.no/tei-mm-2008/index_ms.html
 ===II. Time===

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-present: Hilde Boe, Fotis Jannidis, Federico Meschini, Malte Rehbein, Elena Pierazzo, Justin Tonra
+present: Hilde Bøe, Fotis Jannidis, Federico Meschini, Malte Rehbein, Elena Pierazzo, Justin Tonra, Ellen Nessheim Wiger.
-discussion led by Elena, minutes by Fotis
+Discussion led by Elena, minutes by Fotis
 [I forgot to take down the names of all present, so please add yours in case I missed it.]
@@ Line 16: / Line 16: @@
 ===I textual alteration===
 Addition, deletion, transposition, clarification, substition (should allow for cases like stylisitic rewriting and total rewriting, looser way), restoration, overwriting, immediate/instant correction, functional mark (marked as used, printer marks, later scribe marks), gap for a planned insertion (which has been filled or not)
 ===II. Time===

@@ Line 53: / Line 53: @@
 ===Agenda===
-) Proposal for money for the workshop
+<ol>
-) Meeting in Oxford with James / or Sebastian in Oxford (January would be possible)
+<li>Proposal for money for the workshop</li>
-) Fotis puts minutes on the wiki, link to a google doc
+<li>Meeting in Oxford with James / or Sebastian in Oxford (January would be possible)</li>
-) Malte organizes dates for skype conferences
+<li>Fotis puts minutes on the wiki, links to a google doc</li>

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 groups of problems:
-<ol start="I">
+<ol style="list-style-type:upper-roman">
 <li>textual alterations etc. </li>
 <li>time</li>