Difference between revisions of "Level 1 Schema and Schematron Feedback"

From TEIWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Tester: Enter Your Name: took this section and added note about use of elementSpec)
(removed unused templates for feedback)
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
 
==Tester: Kevin Hawkins==
 
==Tester: Kevin Hawkins==
  
* Most <elementSpec>s have examples that are taken exactly from P5 but do not validate according to the ODD itself.  I recommend omitting all examples from the ODD since creating valid examples for each element is a huge amount of work which makes maintenance of the BP that much harder.
+
* Most <elementSpec>s have examples that are taken exactly from P5 but do not validate according to the ODD itself.  Furthermore, definitions sometimes refer to sections of P5 with pointers such as <code><ptr target="#SACR"/></code> , which don't resolver.  I recommend omitting all element definitions since creation and maintenance of these is too much for us to undertake.
  
==Tester: Enter Your Name==
+
: Later, Syd will change XSLT so that it omits exemplum elements from output.  Some day in the future, we will figure out a mechanism that allows us to supply our own examples not in P5 for use of particular elemens.  The output will include only our examples and none of those in P5.  ([[User:Kshawkin|Kshawkin]] 10:05, 5 July 2011 (EDT))
  
'''Comments/Feedback'''
+
==Tester: Sebastian Rahtz==
  
* List feedback, problems encountered, etc. in bulleted list form.  Provide detailed examples please so that we may make corrections more easily.
+
In an email, Sebastian wrote: <code>surely &amp;amp; inside <egXML> is not intended?</code>
* Feedback
 
* Feedback
 
  
==Tester: Enter Your Name==
+
: fixed by Syd; not yet committed to GitHub ([[User:Kshawkin|Kshawkin]] 10:12, 5 July 2011 (EDT))
 
 
'''Comments/Feedback'''
 
 
 
* List feedback, problems encountered, etc. in bulleted list form.  Provide detailed examples please so that we may make corrections more easily.
 
* Feedback
 
* Feedback
 

Latest revision as of 16:12, 5 July 2011

>>Return to testing instructions: Feedback_on_the_Best_Practices_for_TEI_in_Libraries_ODD_Documentation_and_Schemas

Tester: Kevin Hawkins

  • Most <elementSpec>s have examples that are taken exactly from P5 but do not validate according to the ODD itself. Furthermore, definitions sometimes refer to sections of P5 with pointers such as <ptr target="#SACR"/> , which don't resolver. I recommend omitting all element definitions since creation and maintenance of these is too much for us to undertake.
Later, Syd will change XSLT so that it omits exemplum elements from output. Some day in the future, we will figure out a mechanism that allows us to supply our own examples not in P5 for use of particular elemens. The output will include only our examples and none of those in P5. (Kshawkin 10:05, 5 July 2011 (EDT))

Tester: Sebastian Rahtz

In an email, Sebastian wrote: surely &amp; inside <egXML> is not intended?

fixed by Syd; not yet committed to GitHub (Kshawkin 10:12, 5 July 2011 (EDT))