AnnArbor2012-Actions
Revision as of 15:31, 11 April 2013 by RebeccaWelzenbach (talk | contribs)
A list of actions, those responsible, and what has been done about them from Ann Arbor 2012 face to face meeting of TEI Technical Council
| Who | What | Result |
| KH, LB, PS, and JC | Get more examples from Ranjith of the current state of the output so that we can calculate some statistics on accuracy, and encourage Google towards making this output format public. | samples sent to tei-council on 2012-06-28 |
| SR | will convert the EEBO-TCP <byline> to <signed> , which solves the issue of the EEBO-TCP import; the broader issue of <figure> will be addressed in the discussion of <floatingDiv> later. | done |
| SR | Add <trailer> to att.typed | done |
| RW, JC | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3480609 RW will check TEI documents and outputs to confirm everything licensed CC+BY and BSD2Clause (not CC+BY+SA or otherwise), and will report back about any inconsistencies. JC will close the bug, and a new one will be opened for any issues which emerge. | done (RW investigating others--in progress, but won't be done before the 6/15 release. rw) |
| MH, JC | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3472477 MH to implement change of IDs in output of guidelines | Not for June 2012 release. I've had one shot at this and failed. I will try again when I have time, but it's not release-blocking. |
| MH, RW | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3471119 MH will implement the consensus (no spaces around em dashes used parenthetically). RW will create the styleguide document with help from KH who knows the CMS system already. The text style guide will be deleted. | done |
| JC, KH | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3395448 JC will try to discover whether Virginia is technically still a partner or not. When it’s resolved, KH will implement any changes to the website. | done |
| JC, MH | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3511134 JC and MH will conspire to implement an html:@id for attributes in HTML Guidelines output in the stylesheets. | Done in rev 10655. |
| KH | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3437509 KH will review the whole thread and make a recommendation about the form of @ref, and make the soft deprecation changes to the Guidelines; these will be reviewed by LB. | done |
| SR, PB | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3432520 Finish implementing standard attributes referring to ISOCAT | done |
| PB | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3046288 PB will contact LR and ask him to provide further examples. | done |
| KH | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3041605 KH to close ticket | done |
| JC | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3497369 (JC) Strike the sentence that’s under discussion, because then the paragraph is less confusing. We should also add a new section (12.2.4), which explains that you don’t have to use ids in @from and @to; you can also use any URIs and XPointers with TEI XPointer schemes. | Done |
| MH | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3497356 MH will ask the submitter (and the TEI-L, pointing to the ticket) for any examples of the use of <div> which suggest that <listApp> might be useful (for instance, organization of <apps> into multiple <div> s with @type). | The elementSpec for <listApp> has been completed, with an example provided by SOAS, and a brief explanation has been added to the TC chapter as of rev 10719. The ticket is still open pending review by Council of the changes, but it can be closed if everyone is happy. |
| LB | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3496998 LB will add an additional example of how to combine <lacunaEnd> inside a <rdg> . Ticket will be closed. | done |
| KH | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3475748 KH to implement | done |
| SR to coordinate, KH and GB to assist | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3440771
clarify relationship between <location> and <geo> in the prose of the Guidelines |
done |
| LB | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3458222 LB will add <pc> to pPart.edit and revise the prose accordingly | done (but see note on ticket -- it's a matter of making <pc> reference pPart.edit, not changing its membership) |
| MH | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3500088 MH to re-visit to determine what's unclear and correct Guidelines. | Done in rev 10481. |
| SR | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3423686 Sebastian to nag Ontology SIG | done, tho no resolution |
| PB | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3288293 PB will add a new attribute to att.pointing, called @targetLang. | done |
| JC | http://purl.org/tei/fr/2724997 and http://purl.org/tei/fr/2507305 linking audio/video; JC will write to TEI-L asking for people who are interested in this area to get in touch. He will run the message by Council first. These people will join a Council working group to come back with a consistent proposal to be discussed later at this meeting. | (Not release-blocking) -- Postponed until after LB reports on meeting covering this. |
| MH, SR, LB | MH will write a new section for “How to edit the Guidelines” which explains TEI testing framework in more detail; this will then be checked by SR and LB. | Partially done 2012-09-06. A section on adding a Schematron constraint, along with tests for it, has been inserted into tcw20.xml, but is currently commented out because the CMS can't render it. |
| LB, MH | LB and MH to make sure a new-style inclusion TEI Lite ODD is up to date, regenerate schemas and update prose to match. The result should be packaged and archived as a stable and unchanging resource. | LB has reworked TEI Lite, using inclusion. Council has not yet decided on how it should be archived and/or maintained; see MH's email to council 2012-08-09 for a summary of options being considered. |
| KH, LB, MH | KH will collaborate with LB and MH to carry out the same process of freezing with Tite. | |
| KH | KH will make the Best Practices for TEI in Libraries customization available through the TEI website (we will not incorporate it into our build process because it’s too restrictive); the document itself will be mined for good ideas, and turned into a set of recommendations for changes to the Guidelines. KH to submit tickets for items to be added to the main Guidelines, since most of the items are likely to be independent and can be assessed separately. | added as community customization, adding tickets is pending |
| MH | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3496958 (MH) We leave the content model alone (it’s horrible), but we use this as an example for Council to collaborate on the creation of one or more Schematron constraints which will enforce the presence of at least one <rdg> , to everyone’s edification. | Schematron constraint added, but wrote to Council to check that's what should have been done given comments on ticket (which is still open). |
| JC | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3496954 No action required; JC to close ticket. | done |
| LB | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3496951 LB to create att.witnessed for @wit on <rdg> and <lem> and remove @wit from <rdgGrp> | done at rev 10243 |
| GB | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3496949 GB will review the particular example mentioned on the ticket, and revise and expand it: firstly, use a straightforward witness; secondly add an example for the "unattested" case. | (Needs more discussion--or someone else to implement) |
| JC | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3490054 JC will close ticket with won't fix suggesting it for P6 | done |
| JC | Start wiki page on P6 development ideas http://wiki.tei-c.org/index.php/P6-dev | done |
| SY | SY will send an email to tei-l to encourage people to add their docs to the samples page to keep open the statistical approach in the long term. | done |
| MH | MH look at existing pages for attribute classes and see if there are any examples, try adding an example to att.ascribed class spec to see if it works | Done. Example for @who added to att.ascribed.xml in rev 10491. |
| SR | SR Sebastian will "show all examples" so that at the top it lists examples from the appropriate chapter, and links to that chapter. | done |
| MH | MH to create a wiki page to coordinate adding examples to attribute classes. Since most attribute classes do not have examples, all of us should generate examples to be added to attribute class pages. | Done. Page is at AttsWithoutEgs |
| SR | change build process so that you can't build without examples on attribute classes (once we've actually added examples to those missing them) | |
| MH | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3434990 MH will write a Schematron rule requiring that <lg> contains <l> , <lg> , or <gap> | Done 2012-06-17, in rev 10522. A Schematron test has been added. Documentation on how to add a Schematron constraint, and tests for it, have been added to tcw20.xml, but it's currently commented out because the CMS XSLT can't handle the use of egXML. |
| SR | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3305016 SR will implement the content model proposed by KH on SF | done |
| GB | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3416130 GB will survey the guidelines to see what kind of changes <certainty> within milestone elements would involve. He will report back via email, unless there is great disagreement the FR should be approved and implement. If there is disagreement, address at our next teleconference | Survey done and Council emailed. |
| JC | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3416130 JC will update the ticket in sourceforge to assign to GB and add a note about our decided action | done |
| JC | macro.paraContent out of place in <gram> etc [cf discussion] link to ticket is broken, so group E did not discuss;
Action: JC to find out what happened to this ticket. |
JC: Found ticket at http://purl.org/tei/bug/3376863 needs more discussion. |
| KH | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3500566 Implement proposal 'a' on SF ticket | done |
| KH (was GB) | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3497079 GB to write a comment on the ticket giving examples of citations that would be problematic or confusing according to this proposal. Paul can also provide example citations from his U-M CV project. Kevin will discuss with Gabby and incorporate marked-up examples into proposal and revise proposal if appropriate. Leave ticket open for now | GB commented. Kevin has responded, and after some discussion this ticket has been closed and two new ones created. |
| JC | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3440977 Agreed: Suggest LR to implement. JC will contact him and report back to us if he will not implement. | Done. |
| KH | http://purl.org/tei/fr/2493417 Agreed and implemented but KH to add more examples/prose | done |
| KH | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3480057 KH to close | done |
| KH (was MH) | http://purl.org/tei/bugs/3439587 MH will revise definition of <titleStmt> to no longer imply responsibility for intellectual content only. MH will also investigate adding <distributor> and <publisher> to model.respLike. | <titleStmt> changes done by MH. Issue of <distributor> and <publisher> remains outstanding and is a bit messy. The ticket has now been assigned by JC to KH. JC and KH have completed it. |
| RW | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3496494 RW will adapt defintion of <span> to take better wording from 17.3 | done on 2012-01-15 |
| LB | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3495987 LB will ask Laurent for examples in case we are assuming incorrectly and will look at TEI-L archives. | |
| LB | http://purl.org/tei/fr/2834511 LB will add proposed Schematron rules but not add any other elements without clear use cases. | |
| SR | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3291540 SR will take the ticket. We’ll leave it to SR to decide which of the second list of elements should be included as well. Sebastian will send a list to TEI-L so people could comment on any elements where it would be removed. | Reassigned to GB at following F2F meeting. |
| SR | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3284816 SR to implement. | did faith. Reassigned to JC at following F2F meeting. |
| SR | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3415801 Allow modification of attributes belonging to a class; SR will implement (in long-term). | |
| LB | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3118435 LB to close ticket | done |
| SR | http://purl.org/tei/fr/3426828 SR to close this ticket noting that requestor hasn’t responded. | done |
| MH | http://purl.org/tei/fr/1650195 MH to implement adding <schemaSpec> to model.encodingDescPart. | Done in revs 10314-10317. Ticket closed. |
| JC | FloatingText proposal: JC will reply to the message on TEI-L: In light of the current text and examples in the Guidelines on <floatingText> and <spGrp> , we’d like examples of proposed “floating divs” and how they would differ from <floatingText>s. | Done |
| LB, KH, BB, PS | http://purl.org/tei/bug/3439980 LB to chair an ad hoc council working group on div-liminal to report back on this before next face2face, KH, LB, and PS to be members, others as necessary. | PS has produced list of samples but nothing done since. |
| SR, LB, MH, PB | Audio/Video Facsimiles -- Working group to be chaired by SR, with LB, MH, and possibly PB; to approach TEI-L and others doing work in this area to get outside expertise; an initial proposal or detailed report of progress at next FTF with status reports at teleconferences. | Laurent is coordinating a new ISO workgroup in this area "the idea is to have a TEI customization as a self-standing ISO document that will bring together the heterogeneous format we have in ELAN, Esmeralda, Transcriber, ANVIL, etc. For the time being, knowing Thomas [Schmidt]'s paper by heart is a good start since he introduced most of the core concepts." and there will be a meeting in Berlin Nov 22 which LB plans to attend |
| MH, GB, SY | MH will chair this working group on private URI schemes and their documention, bring in GB, SY, and outside people suggested by GB. They will develop concrete proposals for next FTF meeting with status reports at teleconferences. | Work underway. Description of current state of XPointer play|XPointer and list of Stand-off use cases done. Use cases circulated to TEI-L for consultation. |
| MH | Private Uri Schemes (split from preceding): the issue of Private Uri Schemes, and a method of documenting their use, is not really part of the TEI Pointers issue at all. | A proposal is being developed here: http://wiki.tei-c.org/index.php/Private_URI_Schemes (Have Matteo Romanello, Sebastian Heath, etc. been invited to comment on this?) |
| JC | James will prod the critical apparatus working group before next teleconference. | (Done, but will do again) |
| JC | JC to produce a Council meeting/telco checklist on TEI-C Wiki to ensure we don't forget steps (like asking SIGs if they have technical things they want to report) | Done |
| SY, LB, PB | UIMA, GATE and other tools. SY will follow up offline w/ LB, PB; PB will put SY in touch with others working in UIMA and interested in converting to TEI;PB and SY report back to Council on progress by next FTF | |
| LB, RW | http://purl.org/tei/bugs/3454814 LB will write up guidelines for purging comments and distribute to TEI-Council list, including describing first passes to deal with low-hanging fruit and suggested format for how we should comment going forward from there, work of reviewing and purging comments or turning them into notes will be divided among council members. RW will incorporate language from LB’s guidelines into the style guide when appropriate | Done? |
| MH | http://purl.org/tei/bugs/3454803 MH will compare Chapter CH against the latest version of BCP 47 for inconsistencies | Done in revs 10650 through 10652 (2012-07-08). |
| MH | Create new Jenkins build script for Ubuntu 12.04 server. | Done 2012-06-13. |
| SR, KH | http://purl.org/tei/bugs/3432216 SR: double check FM1 to see if list of translators is up to date; KH will add this policy to the “how to edit the guidelines” working paper | tcw20 now says to leave @version attribute unchanged. Korean translator name added to FM1 |
| PS, RW | http://purl.org/tei/bugs/3223636 Expand our explanation of xml:space in the Guidelines:
|
Done |
| SR | http://purl.org/tei/bugs/3393781 SR per LB’s comment on Sourceforge: Agreed to rename @version in att.translatable as @versionDate and give it a date datatype. We don’t want all the possibilities of att.datable. | done |
| JC | JC to add TEI Sourceforge site to the TEI category so all TEI sourceforge projects can be located at once | done |
